CatallaxCore
← Back to bills

HB 23-1227

signed

Enforce Laws Against Pharmacy Benefit Managers

Plain-English Summary

AI-generated

HB 23-1227, which has been signed into law and will take effect on August 7, 2023, aims to regulate pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) by prohibiting them from engaging in certain practices that could harm pharmacies or patients. These include requiring mail-order prescriptions, charging pharmacies for processing claims, and reducing payments after a sale. The bill also mandates PBMs to provide clear cost information to patients and allow pharmacists to inform patients about more affordable drug alternatives. This law will affect PBMs, pharmacies, and insured individuals by ensuring fair practices and transparency in the prescription drug process.

Official Summary

Under current law, pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) are required to perform certain acts and are prohibited from engaging in certain acts. Specifically, PBMs are prohibited from: Requiring patients to obtain their prescription drugs through mail order; Charging pharmacies fees to adjudicate claims; Requiring pharmacies to obtain accreditations or certifications that are different than what the PBM requires of its affiliated pharmacies; Retroactively reducing a payment made to a pharmacy on a drug claim after the point of sale or reimbursing a pharmacy in an amount that is less than the amount reimbursed to its own affiliated pharmacy for the same pharmacy service; Modifying the prescription drug formulary under a health benefit plan during the plan year; With regard to audits, using specified techniques in calculating a recoupment or penalty, subjecting a pharmacy to recoupment when a clerical error is discovered, and requiring pharmacies to be audited more than once a year; Prohibiting a pharmacy or pharmacist from, or penalizing a pharmacy or pharmacist for, providing information to patients about more affordable, therapeutically equivalent alternatives to a prescribed drug; or Requiring a pharmacy or pharmacist to charge or collect a copayment from an insured patient that exceeds the total charge submitted by the pharmacy for the prescription drug. Additionally, PBMs are required to: Provide pharmacies 7 days' written notice before an audit, conduct an audit by or in consultation with a pharmacist, allow the pharmacy to supplement claims documentation, and establish an appeals process; Provide an insured individual, the insured's health-care provider, or a third party acting on behalf of the insured or provider with up-to-date and real-time cost, benefit, and coverage information under the terms of the insured's health benefit plan; and Provide contracted pharmacies with the list of sources the PBM used in determining maximum allowable cost pricing, update the information every 7 days, allow pharmacies the ability to readily review the information, follow specified requirements when placing a drug on the maximum allowable cost list, and establish an appeals process to resolve disputes. The act specifies that the commissioner of insurance (commissioner) has the power to enforce these prohibitions and requirements and impose penalties on PBMs for failing to comply with these prohibitions and requirements. The commissioner is also authorized to adopt rules as necessary to implement and enforce these prohibitions and requirements. Additionally, the act requires PBMs to register with and pay a registration fee to the commissioner and authorizes the commissioner to deny, suspend, revoke, or refuse to issue, continue, or renew a PBM registration or to issue a cease-and-desist order if the commissioner finds that a PBM has engaged in specified activities, including violating an insurance law. The PBM registration fees imposed under the act are to be used to fund the costs of the division of insurance in enforcing requirements and prohibitions on PBMs. The act appropriates $206,647 from the division of insurance cash fund to the department of regulatory agencies for use by the division of insurance for personal services and operating expenses related to implementing the act. APPROVED by Governor May 10, 2023 EFFECTIVE August 7, 2023 NOTE: This act was passed without a safety clause and takes effect 90 days after sine die. (Note: This summary applies to this bill as enacted.)

Details

Chamber
House
First action
2023-05-10
Latest action
2023-03-02
Last action desc.
Introduced In House - Assigned to Health & Insurance
OpenStates
View source ↗

Sponsors

Related Legislation

This bill affects (126)

amends
HB 23-1116(2023A)· signed
Contracts Between Carriers And Providers
amends
SB 23-189(2023A)· signed
Increasing Access To Reproductive Health Care
amends
HB 18-1440(2018A)· signed
Preneed Funeral Contract Sellers
amends
HB 18-1357(2018A)· signed
Behavioral Health Care Ombudsperson Parity Reports
amends
SB 22-206(2022A)· signed
Disaster Preparedness And Recovery Resources
amends
HB 17-1231(2017A)· signed
Market Conduct Examinations Insurance Companies
amends
HB 22-1284(2022A)· signed
Health Insurance Surprise Billing Protections
amends
HB 22-1122(2022A)· signed
Pharmacy Benefit Manager Prohibited Practices
amends
HB 22-1269(2022A)· signed
Health-care Sharing Plan Reporting Requirements
amends
SB 17-300(2017A)· signed
High-risk Health Care Coverage Program
amends
SB 22-040(2022A)· signed
Actuarial Reviews Health Insurance Mandate Legislation
amends
SB 23-130(2023A)· signed
Department of Regulatory Agencies Supplemental
amends
HB 18-1284(2018A)· signed
Disclosure Of Prescription Costs At Pharmacies
amends
HB 22-1228(2022A)· signed
Sunset Continue Regulate Preneed Funeral Contracts
amends
HB 18-1392(2018A)· signed
State Innovation Waiver Reinsurance Program
amends
SB 22-162(2022A)· signed
Administration Organization Act Modernization
amends
SB 18-132(2018A)· signed
1332 State Waiver Catastrophic Health Plans
amends
SB 17-198(2017A)· signed
Public Participate Review Acquire Control Insurer
amends
SB 17-088(2017A)· signed
Participating Provider Network Selection Criteria
amends
HB 22-1111(2022A)· signed
Insurance Coverage For Loss Declared Fire Disaster
amends
HB 18-1166(2018A)· signed
Supplemental Appropriation - Department Of Regulatory Agencies
amends
HB 17-1278(2017A)· failed
Insurance Premium Tax Deposit To Local Firefighter Fund
amends
SB 17-249(2017A)· signed
Sunset Division Of Insurance
amends
HB 22-1370(2022A)· signed
Coverage Requirements For Health-care Products
amends
HB 22-1278(2022A)· signed
Behavioral Health Administration
relates
SB 22-224(2022A)· signed
Protections For Donor-conceived Persons And Families
relates
SB 18-086(2018A)· signed
Cyber Coding Cryptology For State Records
relates
HB 17-1239(2017A)· signed
Relocate Title 12 Private Occupational Schools
relates
HB 22-1235(2022A)· signed
Sunset Continue Regulation Of Veterinary Practice
relates
SB 17-226(2017A)· signed
Relocate Title 12 Regulation Of Financial Institutions
relates
SB 17-215(2017A)· signed
Sunset Licensed Real Estate Brokers & Subdivision Developers
relates
HB 22-1112(2022A)· signed
Workers' Compensation Injury Notices
relates
SB 18-092(2018A)· signed
Update References County Departments Social Services
relates
SB 22-129(2022A)· signed
Process For Proposed Air Quality Rules
relates
HB 17-1046(2017A)· signed
Update Outdated Statutes Persons With Disabilities
relates
HB 18-1375(2018A)· signed
Revisor's Bill
relates
SB 22-058(2022A)· signed
Dental Hygienists Peer Health Assistance Program
relates
HB 17-1277(2017A)· signed
Driver's License Suspension Leaving Accident Scene
relates
SB 22-154(2022A)· signed
Increasing Safety In Assisted Living Residences
relates
HB 22-1355(2022A)· signed
Producer Responsibility Program For Recycling
relates
SB 17-076(2017A)· signed
Authority To Spend Money For School Awards
relates
HB 23-1111(2023A)· signed
Unauthorized Insurance Premium Tax Rate
relates
HB 17-1278(2017A)· failed
Insurance Premium Tax Deposit To Local Firefighter Fund
relates
HB 23-1121(2023A)· signed
Repeal Of Infrequently Used Tax Expenditures
relates
SB 17-168(2017A)· signed
Supplemental Appropriations Department of Public Safety
relates
HB 18-1131(2018A)· signed
Court System For Remote Participation In Hearings
relates
SB 18-207(2018A)· signed
DHS Department Of Human Services Indirect Cost Assessments From Cash Funds
relates
HB 22-1412(2022A)· signed
Sunset Division Of Gaming
relates
SB 22-212(2022A)· signed
Revisor's Bill
relates
SB 17-065(2017A)· signed
Transparency In Direct Pay Health Care Prices
relates
SB 17-204(2017A)· failed
Improper Denial Of Property And Casualty Claims
relates
HB 23-1021(2023A)· signed
Embargo And Destroy Marijuana
relates
HB 18-1311(2018A)· signed
Single Geographic Rating Area Individual Health Plan
relates
HB 22-1295(2022A)· signed
Department Early Childhood And Universal Preschool Program
relates
HB 22-1370(2022A)· signed
Coverage Requirements For Health-care Products
relates
HB 17-1121(2017A)· failed
Patient Safety Act
relates
HB 18-1165(2018A)· signed
Supplemental Appropriation - Department Of Public Safety
relates
SB 17-240(2017A)· signed
Sunset Motor Vehicle Dealers Sales
relates
HB 18-1384(2018A)· signed
Study Health Care Coverage Options
relates
SB 18-081(2018A)· signed
Emergency Medical Service Providers Licensing
relates
HB 17-1334(2017A)· failed
Registration Process Servers
relates
SB 18-036(2018A)· signed
Relocate Title 24 Tobacco Sales Minors To Title 44
relates
HB 18-1023(2018A)· signed
Relocate Title 12 Marijuana To New Title 44
relates
HB 18-1024(2018A)· signed
Relocate Title 12 Racing to New Title 44
relates
SB 18-234(2018A)· signed
Human Remains Disposition Sale Businesses
relates
SB 17-044(2017A)· signed
Reporting Requirements By DORA To General Assembly
relates
SB 22-225(2022A)· signed
Ambulance Service Sustainability And State Licensing
relates
HB 18-1378(2018A)· signed
Equal Pay For Equal Work Act
relates
HB 18-1224(2018A)· signed
Licensee Discipline Mediation State Agency
relates
HB 17-1051(2017A)· signed
Procurement Code Modernization
relates
SB 17-232(2017A)· signed
Sunset Bingo-raffle Advisory Board
relates
HB 17-1238(2017A)· signed
Relocate Title 12 Credit Debt Services
relates
SB 17-294(2017A)· signed
Revisor's Bill
relates
HB 22-1270(2022A)· signed
Change Term Name-based Criminal History Record Check
relates
SB 18-034(2018A)· signed
Relocate Title 12 Gaming To New Title 44
relates
SB 23-071(2023A)· signed
Education Accountability Act
relates
HB 22-1239(2022A)· signed
Regulate Community Association Managers
relates
HB 18-1260(2018A)· signed
Prescription Drug Price Transparency
relates
SB 17-298(2017A)· signed
Motor Vehicle Dealers And Manufacturers
relates
SB 18-170(2018A)· signed
Reservoir Releases For Fish And Wildlife Mitigation
relates
HB 18-1025(2018A)· signed
Relocate Title 12 Liquor Laws To Title 44
relates
SB 18-167(2018A)· signed
Enforce Requirements 811 Locate Underground Facilities
relates
HB 22-1278(2022A)· signed
Behavioral Health Administration
relates
HB 22-1098(2022A)· signed
Department Of Regulatory Agencies Barriers To Practice Regulated Professions
relates
HB 22-1263(2022A)· signed
Sunset Continue Licensure Of Acupuncturists
relates
SB 23-051(2023A)· signed
Conforming Workforce Development Statutes
relates
HB 18-1114(2018A)· signed
Require License Practice Genetic Counseling
relates
SB 18-091(2018A)· signed
Modernize Behavioral Health Terminology
relates
HB 18-1009(2018A)· signed
Diabetes Drug Pricing Transparency Act 2018
relates
SB 18-132(2018A)· signed
1332 State Waiver Catastrophic Health Plans
relates
SB 23-144(2023A)· signed
Prescription Drugs For Chronic Pain
relates
SB 17-003(2017A)· signed
Repeal Colorado Health Benefit Exchange
relates
SB 18-023(2018A)· signed
Promote Off-label Use Pharmaceutical Products
relates
HB 18-1179(2018A)· signed
Prohibit Price Gouging On Prescription Drugs
relates
SB 23-189(2023A)· signed
Increasing Access To Reproductive Health Care
relates
HB 17-1158(2017A)· signed
Charitable Solicitations Regulation
relates
SB 17-222(2017A)· signed
Relocate Title 12 Fireworks
relates
HB 17-1231(2017A)· signed
Market Conduct Examinations Insurance Companies
relates
HB 18-1027(2018A)· signed
Relocate Title 24 Lottery To New Title 44
relates
HB 18-1291(2018A)· signed
Sunset Conservation Easement Oversight Commission
relates
HB 18-1175(2018A)· signed
Sunset Community Association Managers
relates
SB 22-230(2022A)· signed
Collective Bargaining For Counties
relates
HB 17-1115(2017A)· signed
Direct Primary Health Care Services
relates
HB 17-1263(2017A)· signed
Limited Lines Self-storage Insurance License
relates
SB 17-249(2017A)· signed
Sunset Division Of Insurance
relates
HB 18-1365(2018A)· signed
Primary Care Infrastructure Creation
relates
SB 18-152(2018A)· signed
Prohibit Price Gouging On Prescription Drugs
relates
SB 17-300(2017A)· signed
High-risk Health Care Coverage Program
relates
SB 18-080(2018A)· signed
Wholesale Canadian Drug Importation Program
relates
SB 17-242(2017A)· signed
Modernize Behavioral Health Terminology in Colorado Revised Statutes
relates
HB 18-1358(2018A)· signed
Health Care Charges Billing Required Disclosures
relates
HB 22-1284(2022A)· signed
Health Insurance Surprise Billing Protections
relates
SB 17-225(2017A)· signed
Relocate Title 12 Farm Products And Warehouses
relates
HB 18-1392(2018A)· signed
State Innovation Waiver Reinsurance Program
relates
SB 22-185(2022A)· signed
Security For Colorado Seniors
relates
SB 22-068(2022A)· signed
Provider Tool To View All-payer Claims Database
relates
HB 18-1438(2018A)· signed
Health Care Coverage Reproductive Health Care
relates
SB 22-051(2022A)· signed
Policies To Reduce Emissions From Built Environment
relates
HB 18-1091(2018A)· signed
Dementia Diseases And Related Disabilities
relates
SB 23-093(2023A)· signed
Increase Consumer Protections Medical Transactions
relates
SB 17-038(2017A)· failed
Registration Home Inspectors
relates
SB 18-030(2018A)· signed
Relocate Auto Industry Division To Title 44
relates
SB 22-034(2022A)· signed
Business Filing Address And Name Fraud
relates
HB 18-1206(2018A)· signed
Live & Let Live Act
relates
HB 18-1280(2018A)· signed
Court Appointees For Marijuana Businesses
relates
HB 22-1376(2022A)· signed
Supportive Learning Environments For K-12 Students

Affected by (111)

amends
HB 25-1222(2025A)· signed
Preserving Access to Rural Independent Pharmacies
amends
SB 24-089(2024A)· signed
Firefighter Heart Benefits Trust
amends
HB 26-1343(2026A)· signed
Electronic Process in Competency & Administrative Hearings
amends
HB 26-1046(2026A)· signed
Regulate Earned-Wage Access Services
amends
SB 25-275(2025A)· signed
Nonsubstantive Relocation of Definitions in Colorado Revised Statutes
relates
HB 25-1088(2025A)· signed
Costs for Ground Ambulance Services
relates
SB 23-166(2023A)· signed
Establishment Of A Wildfire Resiliency Code Board
relates
HB 26-1167(2026A)· signed
Department of Regulatory Agencies Supplemental
relates
SB 23-176(2023A)· signed
Protections For People With An Eating Disorder
relates
SB 24-073(2024A)· signed
Maximum Number of Employees to Qualify as Small Employer
relates
HB 24-1119(2024A)· signed
Multi-State Tax Filing System for Insurance Taxes
relates
HB 25-1002(2025B)· signed
Corporate Income Tax Foreign Jurisdictions
relates
HB 26-1267(2026A)· failed
Limitations on Collection Actions for Medical Debt
relates
HB 26-1426(2026A)· signed
Department of Law Legislative Report
relates
HB 23-1257(2023A)· signed
Mobile Home Park Water Quality
relates
HB 25-1296(2025A)· signed
Tax Expenditure Adjustment
relates
HB 24-1149(2024A)· signed
Prior Authorization Requirements Alternatives
relates
HB 26-1064(2026A)· signed
Youthful Offender System Updates
relates
HB 26-1414(2026A)· signed
Medical Record Requests
relates
HB 26-1349(2026A)· signed
Funding for Prevention Services Programs Colorado Department of Early Childhood
relates
HB 25-1303(2025A)· signed
Funding for Motor Vehicle Collision Prevention
relates
HB 23-1174(2023A)· signed
Homeowner's Insurance Underinsurance
relates
HB 23-1136(2023A)· signed
Prosthetic Devices For Recreational Activity
relates
HB 24-1438(2024A)· signed
Implement Prescription Drug Affordability Programs
relates
SB 24-080(2024A)· signed
Transparency in Health-Care Coverage
relates
HB 24-1315(2024A)· signed
Study on Remediation of Property Damaged by Fire
relates
HB 24-1010(2024A)· signed
Insurance Coverage for Provider-Administered Drugs
relates
HB 24-1045(2024A)· signed
Treatment for Substance Use Disorders
relates
HB 25-1302(2025A)· signed
Increase Access Homeowner's Insurance Enterprises
relates
SB 24-139(2024A)· signed
Creation of 911 Services Enterprise
relates
HB 23-1236(2023A)· signed
Implementation Updates To Behavioral Health Administration
relates
HB 25-1269(2025A)· signed
Building Decarbonization Measures
relates
HB 25-1020(2025B)· failed
Additions to Definition Federal Taxable Income
relates
HB 26-1258(2026A)· passed
Changes to Practices Relating to Death
relates
SB 23-179(2023A)· signed
Dental Plans Medical Loss Ratio
relates
HB 23-1002(2023A)· signed
Epinephrine Auto-injectors
relates
HB 24-1198(2024A)· signed
Department of Regulatory Agencies Supplemental
relates
HB 24-1040(2024A)· signed
Gender-Affirming Health-Care Provider Study
relates
HB 24-1108(2024A)· signed
Insurance Commissioner Study Insurance Market
relates
HB 24-1382(2024A)· signed
Insurance Coverage Pediatric Neuropsychiatric Syndrome
relates
SB 24-161(2024A)· signed
Parks & Wildlife Licenses & Passes
relates
SB 24-229(2024A)· signed
Ozone Mitigation Measures
relates
HB 24-1260(2024A)· signed
Prohibition Against Employee Discipline
relates
SB 24-089(2024A)· signed
Firefighter Heart Benefits Trust
relates
SB 23-167(2023A)· signed
Board Of Nursing Regulate Certified Midwives
relates
HB 24-1078(2024A)· signed
Regulation of Community Association Managers
relates
HB 24-1328(2024A)· signed
Sunset Continue Money Transmitter Regulation
relates
SB 25-194(2025A)· signed
Sunset Dental Practice Act
relates
HB 25-1209(2025A)· signed
Marijuana Regulation Streamline
relates
HB 24-1060(2024A)· signed
Travel Insurance Consumer Protections
relates
HB 24-1316(2024A)· signed
Middle-Income Housing Tax Credit
relates
HB 24-1434(2024A)· signed
Expand Affordable Housing Tax Credit
relates
HB 26-1065(2026A)· signed
Transit and Housing Investment Zones
relates
SB 26-178(2026A)· signed
Health Insurance Affordability Measures
relates
SB 23-205(2023A)· signed
Universal High School Scholarship Program
relates
HB 24-1043(2024A)· signed
State Contribution to Fire & Police Pension Association Death & Disability Fund
relates
HB 24-1466(2024A)· signed
Refinance Federal Coronavirus Recovery Funds
relates
SB 25-310(2025A)· signed
Proposition 130 Implementation
relates
SB 25-262(2025A)· signed
Changes to Money in the Capital Construction Fund
relates
SB 25-317(2025A)· signed
Transfer Cash Fund Investment Earnings to General Fund
relates
SB 25-261(2025A)· signed
Property Tax Deferral Program Administration
relates
HB 26-1332(2026A)· signed
Legislative Department Cash Fund
relates
SB 24-093(2024A)· signed
Continuity of Health-Care Coverage Change
relates
SB 25-045(2025A)· signed
Health-Care Payment System Analysis
relates
HB 25-1222(2025A)· signed
Preserving Access to Rural Independent Pharmacies
relates
SB 23-288(2023A)· signed
Coverage For Doula Services
relates
SB 25-106(2025A)· signed
Department of Regulatory Agencies Supplemental
relates
HB 26-1046(2026A)· signed
Regulate Earned-Wage Access Services
relates
HB 23-1126(2023A)· signed
Consumer Reports Not Include Medical Debt Information
relates
HB 23-1215(2023A)· signed
Limits On Hospital Facility Fees
relates
HB 26-1188(2026A)· signed
Sunset Process Securities Regulation
relates
HB 26-1287(2026A)· signed
Sunset Division of Real Estate
relates
HB 26-1289(2026A)· signed
Modification of Certain Tax Expenditures
relates
SB 26-113(2026A)· signed
Require Recovery Residences to Obtain Behavioral Health Administration License
relates
SB 26-138(2026A)· signed
Reducing Administrative Burdens on Health Care
relates
HB 23-1301(2023A)· signed
Revisor's Bill
relates
SB 24-176(2024A)· signed
Update Medicaid Member Terminology
relates
HB 24-1359(2024A)· signed
Public Notification of Hazardous Chemical Releases
relates
HB 24-1381(2024A)· signed
Sunset Division of Financial Services
relates
HB 24-1095(2024A)· signed
Increasing Protections for Minor Workers
relates
HB 24-1004(2024A)· signed
Ex-Offenders Practice in Regulated Occupations
relates
SB 24-198(2024A)· signed
Regulated Natural Medicine Implementation
relates
SB 25-119(2025A)· signed
Measures to Modify the Department of Early Childhood
relates
HB 25-1076(2025A)· signed
Motor Vehicle Regulation Administration
relates
HB 25-1262(2025A)· signed
Regulate Private Security Officers & Agencies
relates
HB 26-1145(2026A)· signed
Mobile Home Park Water Quality
relates
HB 24-1075(2024A)· signed
Analysis of Universal Health-Care Payment System
relates
HB 25-1002(2025A)· signed
Medical Necessity Determination Insurance Coverage
relates
SB 25-198(2025A)· signed
Transparency Transactions Medical Care Entities
relates
HB 25-1174(2025A)· signed
Reimbursement Requirements for Health Insurers
relates
HB 25-1064(2025A)· signed
Prohibition on Cultivated Meat
relates
SB 24-086(2024A)· signed
Breast Cancer Screening Fund Transfer
relates
SB 25-308(2025A)· signed
Medicaid Services Related to Federal Authorizations
relates
HB 23-1225(2023A)· signed
Extend And Modify Prescription Drug Affordability Board
relates
HB 23-1224(2023A)· signed
Standardized Health Benefit Plan
relates
HB 23-1288(2023A)· signed
Fair Access To Insurance Requirements Plan
relates
SB 23-285(2023A)· signed
Energy And Carbon Management Regulation In Colorado
relates
SB 23-290(2023A)· signed
Natural Medicine Regulation And Legalization
relates
HB 24-1352(2024A)· signed
Appliance Requirements & Incentives
relates
SB 24-126(2024A)· signed
Conservation Easement Income Tax Credit
relates
HB 26-1056(2026A)· failed
Prescription Drug Benefit Information Transparency
relates
SB 26-167(2026A)· signed
Prescription Drug Out-of-Pocket Expense Credit
relates
SB 25-277(2025A)· signed
Sunset Title Insurance Commission
relates
HB 23-1201(2023A)· signed
Prescription Drug Benefits Contract Term Requirements
relates
HB 24-1380(2024A)· signed
Regulation of Debt-Related Services
relates
HB 24-1353(2024A)· signed
Firearms Dealer Requirements & Permit
relates
HB 25-1020(2025A)· signed
Earned-Wage Access Service Provider
relates
SB 26-192(2026A)· passed
Producer Responsibility Dues Appeals Process
repeals
HB 25-1268(2025A)· signed
Utility On-Bill Repayment Program Financing
repeals
HB 24-1453(2024A)· signed
Relocate Title 24 CLIMBER Act
repeals
HB 24-1470(2024A)· signed
Eliminate Premium Tax to Health Insurance Affordability Fund

Votes

REPASS
2023-05-02 · House · passYes: 55 · No: 10 · Other:
CONCUR
2023-05-02 · House · passYes: 63 · No: 2 · Other:
BILL
2023-05-01 · Senate · passYes: 26 · No: 9 · Other:
BILL
2023-04-13 · House · passYes: 55 · No: 9 · Other: