SB 17-181
failedCollateral-Source Rule Evidence Of Insurance
Plain-English Summary
AI-generatedSenate Bill 17-181 changes how insurance and other compensation sources are considered in personal injury lawsuits. Traditionally, juries don't know about these sources, but this bill allows evidence of them unless the plaintiff agrees to have their award reduced by either what they've received from or paid into those sources. However, if a defendant is convicted for repeat alcohol-related driving offenses causing injuries, the old rule still applies and no reductions are made based on collateral sources. The bill has been signed into law, meaning these changes will now be implemented in Colorado's legal system.
Official Summary
The bill modifies the collateral-source rule, which generally states that in a civil action for damages the jury should not be told about insurance coverage or other sources from which the plaintiff has received or may receive compensation (collateral sources). The bill allows evidence of collateral sources unless the plaintiff agrees to have the jury's award reduced by the lesser of:
The amount paid or available to the plaintiff from collateral sources; or
The amount of premiums or other contributions the plaintiff paid to those collateral sources.
The bill establishes the procedure for determining these amounts and the conditions under which the plaintiff may elect to invoke the collateral-source rule.
The bill retains the original collateral-source rule, without the changes specified above, if the defendant has been convicted of a second or subsequent alcohol-related driving offense that resulted in injury.
(Note: This summary applies to the reengrossed version of this bill as introduced in the second house.)
Details
- Chamber
- Senate
- First action
- 2017-04-19
- Latest action
- 2017-02-14
- Last action desc.
- Introduced In Senate - Assigned to Judiciary
- OpenStates
- View source ↗
Related Legislation
This bill affects (2)
relatesSB 17-182(2017A)· failedUninsured Motor Vehicle And Medical Coverage
relatesSB 17-004(2017A)· failedAccess To Providers For Medicaid Recipients
Affected by (19)
amendsHB 22-1295(2022A)· signedDepartment Early Childhood And Universal Preschool Program
amendsSB 17-227(2017A)· signedRelocate Title 12 Attorneys-at-law
amendsHB 22-1089(2022A)· signedRideshares And Uninsured Motorist Insurance Coverage
amendsHB 26-1096(2026A)· failedColorado Medicaid Access to Primary Care Services
amendsHB 22-1289(2022A)· signedHealth Benefits For Colorado Children And Pregnant Persons
relatesHB 24-1146(2024A)· signedMedicaid Provider Suspension for Organized Fraud
relatesSB 24-176(2024A)· signedUpdate Medicaid Member Terminology
relatesHB 26-1412(2026A)· signedDepartment of Health Care Policy & Financing Statistical Sampling & Extrapolation
relatesHB 24-1440(2024A)· signedProperty & Casualty Insurance Documents & Forms
relatesHB 23-1295(2023A)· signedAudits Of Department Of Health Care Policy And Financing Payments To Providers
relatesHB 17-1115(2017A)· signedDirect Primary Health Care Services
relatesHB 17-1139(2017A)· signedMedicaid Provider Compliance Billing Safety Rules
relatesSB 18-092(2018A)· signedUpdate References County Departments Social Services
relatesHB 18-1211(2018A)· signedMedicaid Fraud Control Unit
relatesHB 18-1431(2018A)· signedStatewide Managed Care System
relatesHB 26-1267(2026A)· failedLimitations on Collection Actions for Medical Debt
repealsSB 25-314(2025A)· signedRecovery Audit Contractor Program
Votes
Refer Senate Bill 17-181 to the Committee of the Whole. The motion passed on a vote of 3-2.
2017-04-19 · House · pass — Yes: 3 · No: 2 · Other: —
Refer Senate Bill 17-181 to the Committee of the Whole. The motion failed on a vote of 3-6.
2017-04-19 · House · fail — Yes: 3 · No: 6 · Other: —
Postpone Senate Bill 17-181 indefinitely. The motion passed on a vote of 6-3.
2017-04-19 · House · pass — Yes: 6 · No: 3 · Other: —